Articles

The Sutyagin case: Prosecutors try to mislead jury

Court hearings of the case of Igor Sutyagin, accused by the Russian Security Service, FSB, of treason, began in Moscow on Nov. 3rd. On the second day, after spending the first selecting a jury, Judge Petr Shtunder of the Moscow City Court had to suspend the hearings, due to the prosecutors´ use of irrelevant or already declared invalid material. (04-NOV-03)

Published: November 4, 2003

As soon as the prosecutors addressed the jury, it became clear that material having nothing to do with the case (for example, charges already dropped during investigation) or claims that are not supported by any available evidence were part of their presentation. The defense, which had anticipated this, tried to exclude this material and have the court declare invalid any claims from the indictment during preliminary hearings in September. Judge Shtunder, however, decided to leave it all in on the prosecutor´s assurance that none of the material that is not directly relevant to the actual charges would be read in front of the jury. When the prosecutors reneged on their own promise, Judge Shtunder immediately called off the hearings, and announced that they will resume on Nov. 5th.

For further details, see previous entries on the Sutyagin case below.

Human Rights Watch prepared a brief considering the Sutyagin case in the context of other recent “espionage cases” in Russia:
http://hrw.org/backgrounder/eca/russia/index.htm

Latest

Opinion

November 21, 2024

Serbia’s Shrinking Civic Space Needs International Attention

In recent months, Serbia has witnessed an alarming crackdown on its civic space. This has unfolded through a wave of arrests, smear campaigns, and repressive tactics aimed at silencing dissent and undermining democratic principles. These actions, exacerbated by growing Russian and Chinese influence, reveal a systematic effort of Serbia’s authorities to suppress civil society and stifle public dissent.

Statements

November 7, 2024

EU Leaders Should Raise Human Rights Crisis in Azerbaijan during COP29

Human Rights House Foundation joins a joint-statement from INGOs led by Human Rights Watch urging EU leaders to press the Azerbaijani Authorities to end its renewed and intensified crackdown on critical voices and independent civil society.

Impact

October 31, 2024

Advocating for increased support for civil society, and marking 30 years of the Network of Human Rights Houses

From October 7-11, 2024, 15 human rights defenders from Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Russia, Serbia, and Ukraine gathered for a week of advocacy as a part of the Network of Human Rights Houses’ 30th anniversary celebrations. Human Rights House Foundation (HRHF) and Network partners aimed to deepen engagement with Norwegian policymakers and raise awareness of critical human rights challenges across the region, emphasising the need for increased political and financial support from Norway for civil society.