Post-election crackdown on independent media continues in Belarus

Two months after the presidential elections in Belarus, independent media outlets and human right defenders are still facing unprecedented levels of repression and harassment and the numbers of prosecutions are on the increase. Three journalists are still held in detention. All those who have been prosecuted continue to face the possibility of long years of imprisonment.

Freedom of expression organisation Article 19 calls on the Belarusian Government to immediately release all journalists, opposition activists and human rights defenders prosecuted for taking part in post-election protests, including those currently under home arrest.

In addition, the organisation calls on the Belarusian Government to cease all other forms of harassments of media workers and assure that freedom of expression becomes a reality for all in the country.

Since the post-election crackdown in December 2010, Article 19 has been closely monitoring the situation of independent media outlets, opposition activists and human rights defenders in Belarus.

The main Article’s 19 concerns about the current situation include:

Criminal prosecution of journalists
Currently, there are 16 journalists and activists who are still being prosecuted for taking part in the post election demonstrations in December 2010. Among those are six members of the Belarusian Association of Journalists: Natalia Radina, Irina Khalip, Dmitri Bondarenko, Pavel Severinec, Sergey Voznyak and Aleksandr Feduta.

Although Natalia Radina, Irina Khalip and Sergey Voznyak who were all released from detention on 28 January 2011.

Irina Khalip remains under house arrest and Natalia Radina has been ordered not to travel outside the city in which she is registered as a resident. All three are also denied of all means of communication with the outside world by the national security agency.

National security officers are permanently stationed in Khalip’s apartment and control her compliance with the conditions of the house arrest. Khalip is not allowed to answer phone calls, to send and receive any correspondence and is prevented from talking to anybody apart from her family members.

Three journalists are still held in detention. All those who have been prosecuted continue to face the possibility of 15 years of imprisonment if they’re cases proceed to trial.

Violations of procedural rights of prosecuted
Those who are under investigation are facing serious violations of their procedural rights in the investigation process, as provided by the international standards and by the Belarusian criminal law, including the right to legal representation.

For example, in case of Irina Khalip, three lawyers so far have signed a contract to represent her; however all later resigned allegedly because

Opposition leader Boris Nemtsov holds a portrait of imprisoned journalist Irina Khalip during a rally in front of the Belarusian Embassy in Moscow, 2011.

of external pressures. Other imprisoned journalists have limited access to their lawyers, who only see their defendants – in the best case – only during some of the interrogations. For example, all requests made by the lawyer of Pavel Severinec to meet with his defendant were rejected until the end of January 2011. He was only able to meet his client during the interrogation.

 

Similarly, journalist Aleksandr Feduta was also only able to meet his lawyer during the interrogations. All requests made by lawyers to meet with their clients separately were rejected by state prosecution.

The Belarusian Ministry of Justice on 17 December suspended licenses of several lawyers who defended the accused of organizing “mass riots” in Minsk on 19 December 2010. They are Uladzimir Toustsik and Tamara Haraeva, lawyers of Iryna Khalip, as well as Aleh and Tatsiana Aheeus, who defended ex-presidential candidate Ales Mikhalevich.

Threats and intimidations of independent media
Article 19 is also concerned about threats and intimidations faced by independent media and activists on a continual basis.

These include anonymous threats made in January to the chief editor, Nikolay Aleksandrov, of newspaper “Brest Courier” in which he was warned against publishing any further articles on presidential candidates or opposition representatives.

Another case is the imprisonment of the correspondent of the Polish newspaper “Gazety Wyborczej” Andrzej Paczobut, who was accused of “taking part” in the unauthorized mass public action on 19 December, 2011 and sent to jail for fifteen days. Initially he was fined, but the state prosecution considered it as a very “light” punishment and appealed the initial court ruling, so the court conducted a repeated hearing and fine was replaced by fifteen days of imprisonment.

On 10 February, 2011, an official warning from the prosecutor general was issued to Boris Gorki, journalist of “Radio Racyja” in relation to his work with foreign media without accreditation. Boris spent 14 days in prison f for “taking part” in the unauthorised mass public action on 19 December, 2011.

Restrictive media legislation
The media legislation of Belarus remains severely restrictive and the situation seems to be worsening. Article 19 is extremely concerned that in the aftermath of the December 2010 media crackdown, the Minister of Information, Aleh Pralaskouski, suggested further restrictive changes to the Media Law and proposed to introduce a compulsory state registration of all internet based media.

Despite strict internet regulations from 2010, internet remains a venue for free distribution of unbiased information in Belarus and subjecting it to further restriction would have dire consequences in the country.

Article 19 condemns the failure of the Belarusian Government to heed calls from international and regional bodies, such as the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), to respect and protection of human rights, including freedom of expression.

Release all journalists!
Article 19 calls on the Belarusian Government to take immediate measures to:

• Immediately release all journalists and activists imprisoned after the events in the aftermath of the presidential elections on 19 December 2010 and remove house arrest and communication limitations imposed;
• Drop all charges brought against those prosecuted for exercising their right to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly during December 2010 protests;
• Take all measures necessary to protect individual journalists and media outlets against threats and intimidations;
• To start the reform of media legislation in line with international obligations of Belarus and involve the potential, expertise and recommendations of international organisations.

Article 19 also calls upon international bodies, especially the UN, the OSCE and the European mechanisms, to closely monitor the situation in Belarus and continue to create pressure on the Government to fulfill its international human rights obligations.

According to the organization, international community should continue the efforts to protect the rights of the journalists and media in Belarus and tackle the issue with the Belarusian authorities.

Related articles:

Treatment of journalists in Belarus resembles torture

Stand up for Ales Bialiatski!

"Justice" in Belarus: lawyers afraid to defend political prisoners

Show case: Belarusian political prisoners ‘released’

Belarusian lawyers need moral support amid government’s pressure

Belarus: repressions against journalists and writers

Belarus flooded with political repression

End of "liberalization" in Belarus

Election aftermath in Belarus: 600 arrested, hundreds injured

Latest

November 19, 2018

Belarus needs “true desire” to improve human rights

Following its first review of Belarus in 21 years, the UN Human Rights Committee concluded that there are “many issues to address.” Human rights defenders warn that these findings need to translate to changes in the country.

November 12, 2018

Трэнінг «Распрацоўка праектных заявак і асноўныя аспекты праектнага менеджменту»

У вас ёсць ідэя, як абараніць альбо прасунуць правы чалавека ці дэмакратычныя каштоўнасці, але вы не зусім разумееце, як яе рэалізаваць? У вас ёсць ідэя, але няма партнёраў, і вы не ведаеце, дзе іх шукаць? У вас ёсць ідэя, вы ведаеце, як яе рэалізаваць, ёсць партнёры, але не ведаеце, дзе і як знайсці падтрымку? У вас няма альбо зусім малы досвед працы з праектамі, вонкавым фінансаваннем і справаздачнасцю? Калі перад вамі паўсталі такія пытанні – прыміце ўдзел у трэнінгу «Распрацоўка праектных заявак і асноўныя аспекты праектнага менеджменту».

November 6, 2018

Конкурс на падтрымку праектаў у галіне правоў чалавека і дэмакратычных каштоўнасцяў

Беларускі дом правоў чалавека імя Б. Звозскава абвяшчае конкурс на падтрымку праектаў, накіраваных на абарону і прасоўванне правоў чалавека і дэмакратычных каштоўнасцяў. Конкурс ладзіцца пры фінансавай падтрымцы Еўрасаюза. Заяўкі на конкурс прымаюцца да 28 лютага 2019 года.