Crimea: The rule of Kremlin prevails over the rule of law

Now three years since the Russian annexation of Crimea, Human Rights House Foundation (HRHF) again raised concerns about the human rights situation on the peninsula at the United Nations Human Rights Council.

“The rule of the Kremlin prevails over the rule of law and the de facto authorities repeatedly abuse their dominance, empowered by a strong sense of impunity,” stated HRHF on 22 March at the Human Rights Council.

HRHF, in its statement prepared in close cooperation with its partner NGOs working on Crimea, urged the international community to further scrutinise the human rights situation in Crimea, and highlighted the significant restrictions imposed on Crimeans by the Russian authorities on the fundamental freedoms of expression, assembly and association. These restrictions were also stressed by the representative of Germany, who highlighted continued violations of the rights of Crimeans to the freedoms of assembly and association. 

Condemnation of the Russian annexation of Crimea was once again issued by several delegations at the Council. The delegation of Denmark stated that the illegal annexation of Crimea by Russia marked the beginning of the deteriorating human rights situation.  

In its statement, HRHF called on the international community to further scrutinise the human rights situation in Crimea, and to take all measures to ensure that the de facto authorities, and their supporters, are made aware of the international community’s attention to their actions, in order to hold them accountable. In an opinion piece in December 2016, Tetiana Pechonchyk, Head of the Human Rights Information Centre, and Florian Irminger, Head of Advocacy at HRHF, underlined that the international community must clearly hold accountable the de facto authorities in Crimea and their supporters, as well as the Russian Federation.

However, the de facto authorities make it difficult for international monitors to gain access to the peninsula. This issue of lack of access to Crimea and the areas of conflict in Eastern Ukraine for international monitoring bodies was raised by the Czech Republic, who called for “authorities to grant unhindered access to the OHCHR to all areas of Ukraine and Crimea”, and by the Council of Europe who expressed hope that their monitoring bodies “will have full, free and unhindered access to all parts of Ukraine”. 

HRHF warned that the de facto authorities, as part of their effort to limit the spreading of information about human rights violations, target human rights defenders, lawyers, and journalists monitoring the situation and reporting about it to the outside world. Leader of one of HRHF’s partner organisations working on Crimea, Olha Skrypnyk from the Crimean Human Rights Group was recently held, along with two colleagues, for seven hours by Russian FSB (Federal Security Service), as they were carrying out regular monitoring of a border-crossing checkpoint. 

Further, HRHF warned that anti-extremism and anti-terrorism laws are utilised in order to criminalise non-violent behaviour, suppress dissent, and exploit judicial and law enforcement systems as instruments to clamp down on opposition voices. 

Criminal prosecutions have been launched against journalists and media workers reporting on human rights violations in Crimea, or who have mentioned it as a territory of Ukraine.

Crimean journalists, Andriy Klymenko (BlackSeaNews), Anna Andrievska (Center for Journalism Investigation) have had criminal cases launched against them, while Mykola Semena (Radio Liberty / Radio Free Europe) is on trial for charges of “separatism” and could face up to five years in prison for publishing an article underlining that Crimea is Ukrainian territory. 

Lawyers such as Mark Feigin, Nikolay Polozov, Emil Kurbedinov and Edem Semedlyayev have been repeatedly subjected to harassment and pressure due to their professional activities. On 26 January 2017, Crimean Tatar lawyer Emil Kurbedinov was sentenced to 10 days of administrative arrest for disseminating what was deemed extremist material. “This increased pressure is emblematic of the continuous interference of the de facto authorities in the conduct of the professional activities of lawyers,” stated HRHF. 

The treatment of the Tatar people in Crimea was also addressed at the session by the European Union, which raised its concerns over their persecution.  

Human rights violations have also been committed by paramilitary groups, such as the self-styled Crimean self-defence force, who have not been held accountable.



October 18, 2018

Court rejects Mehman Huseynov’s appeal for conditional release

The Azerbaijani video journalist found no justice in his trial for defamation, and in August his first application for conditional release was rejected. His so far unsuccessful appeals against this rejection include an accuser not summoned to court and warnings against informing people of their rights. Such events are a repeat of the injustices that took place during his arrest and trial.

October 17, 2018

Political leaders in Georgia must stop slandering civil society organisations

Some 49 member and partner NGOs of 13 Human Rights Houses issue a joint letter to political leaders in Georgia.

October 3, 2018

Human Rights in Theatre: “Justice for the Dictator”

Human rights organisations in Voronezh, Russia, staged the play “Justice for the Dictator”, a performance reading of the play “The Trial of Mussolini”. Once again, they showed their creative and innovative approach to reaching out on human rights.