Discrimination as Armenia discusses universal periodic review in parliament. Photo: parliament.am

Discrimination as Armenia discusses Universal Periodic Review

During follow-up discussions of Armenia’s universal periodic review in April 2019, Chairperson of the Standing Committee on Protection of Human Rights and Public Affairs Naira Zohrabyan gave a discriminatory speech relating to issues of transgender people. Some 20 Armenian Human Rights NGOs, including Human Rights House Yerevan, issued the following statement calling on the Armenian authorities to examine the incident and condemn the speech made by Zohrabyan.

Naira Zohrabyan’s response was discriminatory

On April 5, the Standing Committee on Human Rights and Public Affairs of the National Assembly initiated a discussion on Universal Periodic Review of the United Nations, in which representatives of the Government, the National Assembly, as well as representatives of international organizations and local civil society participated.

It should be noted that this discussion was the first in its kind when the UN Universal Periodic Review Recommendations were debated in the National Assembly with the involvement and participation of various stakeholders.

Given the importance of everyone’s involvement in the process of human rights protection, we welcome,

a. This initiative of the RA NA Standing Committee on Protection of Human Rights and Public Affairs, which gives an opportunity to thoroughly and effectively discuss the situation of human rights and existing problems in the Republic of Armenia as well as to find their possible solutions through effective usage of the UN’s UPR.

b. Involvement of the Government of the Republic of Armenia, in particular representatives of the Ministry of Justice, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs, and other state institutions in this process and the readiness to cooperate in the framework of the UPR.

c. The active involvement of the Human Rights Defender Institute in these processes.

It is noteworthy that during the discussion on the Universal Periodic Review, both civil society representatives and Government representatives emphasized the need for elaboration and adoption of comprehensive legislation envisaging effective mechanisms against discrimination. The necessity of introducing effective mechanisms for the protection of all groups of the society, including the rights of minorities was emphasized several times.

However, during the speeches, the chairperson of the NGO “Right Side”, trans woman Lilit Martirosyan, Chairperson of the NA Standing Committee on Protection of Human Rights and Public Affairs Naira Zohrabyan spoke out loudly about the speech, noting that the issues of transgender  individuals were not on the agenda; talking about that topic is disrespectful to her and to the parliament.

It is noteworthy that such limitations were not provided in the pre-published communications on the parliamentary hearings and on the agenda and other speeches during the hearings were not met with the same level of outrage. Moreover, the agenda included the issue of strengthening the principle of anti-discrimination, which was fully consistent with Lilit Martirosyan’s speech.

We consider Ms. Zohrabyan’s response to Lilit Martirosyan’s speech as discriminatory and degrading and call on RA NA President, other NA members to:

  • Make public statements condemning Naira Zohrabyan’s speech,
  • Invite the NA Ethics Committee and examine this incident,
  • Reconsider the expediency of holding Naira Zohrabyan’s position as the Chair of the Standing Committee on Human Rights and Public Affairs.

Pink human rights defender NGO
Right Side human rights defender NGO
Human Rights House Yerevan
Non-Discrimination and Equality Coalition
Human Rights Research Center
Helsinki Citizens Assembly Vanadzor Office
New Generation humanitarian NGO
Center for Legal Initiatives NGO
Women’s Resource Center NGO
Real World, Real People NGO
“Socioscope” Societal Research and Consultancy Center NGO
“Women in Black, Armenia” peacebuilding initiative
Transparency International Anti-Corruption Center
Colorful House Social-cultural and Human Rights Defender NGO
Women’s Support Center NGO
Society without Violence NGO
Spitak Helsinki Group human rights NGO
Sexual Assault Crisis Center
Legal Analyses and Development Center
Coalition to Stop Violence against Women

Statement originally published at: pinkarmenia.org

Thumbnail photo: parliament.am


September 17, 2019

Паролі, антывірусы, шыфраванне дыскаў: трэнінг Школы лічбавай бяспекі DSS375

У Беларускім доме правоў чалавека імя Барыса Звозскава ў верасні 2019 года адбыўся трэнінг лічбавай бяспекі для праваабаронцаў, грамадскіх актывістаў і незалежных журналістаў.

September 16, 2019

Much-needed reforms to Council of Europe reprisal mechanism

The Secretary General of the Council of Europe, Thorbjørn Jagland, has announced much-needed reforms to the human rights body’s “reprisal mechanism” – launched in May 2017 to ensure “human rights defenders… never face retribution for their principled stance.”

September 9, 2019

HRHF priorities at Human Rights Council 42

Gain insight into HRHF’s priorities alongside partners for the 42nd session of the United Nations Human Rights Council #HRC42. The Council session will run from 9-27 September 2019.