UK: defamation decriminalized

OSCE media freedom watchdog Miklos Haraszti welcomes United Kingdom’s decriminalisation of defamation, urges other states to follow. ‘This is a crucial achievement not only for the country’s own freedom of speech, but a great encouragement to many other nations,’ Haraszti said.

“The United Kingdom is the first among the Western European participating States in the OSCE to officially decriminalize defamation.

This is a crucial achievement not only for the country’s own freedom of speech, but a great encouragement to many other nations which are still to pursue such a reform,” Haraszti said.

An amendment to the Coroners and Justice Act decriminalized defamation, sedition and seditious libel, defamatory libel and obscene libel in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

The Coroners and Justice Bill was given Royal Assent and became an Act of Parliament (law) at 16h47 on 12 November 2009.

“My Office has recommended the decriminalization of defamation for several years. Although these obsolete provisions have not been used in Western Europe for decades, their ‘chilling effect’ remained.

Their existence has served as justification for states unwilling to stop criminalization of journalistic errors, and leave those offences solely to the civil-law domain,” Haraszti said.

“I urge other participating States to speed up reforms and end criminal libel,” he said.”Defamation is a criminal offence in all except nine OSCE participating States — Bosnia and Herzegovina, Cyprus, Estonia, Georgia, Moldova, Romania, Ukraine, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

In most countries it is punishable by imprisonment, substantially ‘chilling’ critical speech in the media. Most imprisoned journalists have been convicted for defamation.”

ARTICLE 19 calls to reform civil defamation
In a statement on defamation decriminalization, ARTICLE 19 welcomes this step:

‘ARTICLE 19 and our partners have been campaigning for the decriminalisation of defamation in the UK for several years.

Criminal defamation has not been used in the UK since the 1970s, but its "chilling effect" remains. Moreover, states around the world justify their persistent use of criminal defamation according to the example set by the UK.

In many countries, criminal defamation laws are abused by the powerful to limit criticism and to stifle public debate. The threat of harsh criminal sanctions, especially imprisonment, exerts a profound chilling effect on freedom of expression.’

Now that defamation has been decriminalised, ARTICLE 19 calls on the government to reform the UK’s over-broad civil defamation laws:

‘In particular, the laws should require that plaintiffs should prove the falsity of statements, block foreign plaintiffs from using UK courts to silence non-UK speakers, require courts to consider the public interest in publication, limit excessive lawyers’ fees, which can currently run into millions of pounds in a single case, and update the laws to better protect Internet publications.’

Latest

January 27, 2021

Патрабуем неадкладнага перагляду прысудаў і вызвалення 31 палітычнага зняволенага

Пераслед гэтых асобаў носіць палітычна матываваны характар, а самі асобы з’яўляюцца палітычнымі зняволенымі.

January 27, 2021

Спыніць ціск на арганізацыі грамадзянскай супольнасьці ў сувязі з рэалізацыяй іх права на доступ да фінансаваньня

21 студзеня Дэпартамэнт фінансавых расследаваньняў Камітэту дзяржаўнага кантролю распачаў праверку Асьветніцкай праваабарончай установы “Офіс па правах людзей з інваліднасьцю”.

January 27, 2021

House-to-House 2021: Call for applications

Human Rights House Foundation announces a call for applications to House-to-House Project Fund 2021. HRHF welcomes all Human Rights Houses, their member organisations as well as organisations and actors from outside of the network to apply for funding.